Obama has critics, supporters at ND

May 18, 2009

By Jesse Davis The Goshen News Mon May 18, 2009, 12:22 AM EDT

SOUTH BEND — The 164th commencement ceremonies at the University of Notre Dame were interrupted by screaming protesters during President Barack Obama’s comments to graduating students.

“You owe an apology to the mother of God!” one man screamed repeatedly from the back of the Joyce Center before and while being escorted out by a combination of law enforcement, secret service and university staff. He was one of four removed from the event for angry outbursts.

“I felt like it was really distracting with the people in the audience giving these outbursts,” Jill Mazur, a Pre-med and English graduate from Pittsburgh, Pa., said. “It really turned the attention away from the graduates it became a political issue, it became so many other issues, and the focus should have stayed with the graduating seniors because that’s what it’s all about, and I didn’t feel that here, at my own graduation.”

Mazur said she didn’t think Obama should have addressed the abortion issue at all, arguing that a commencement address is the wrong arena for the topic.

“I just feel like if they wanted a true dialogue, they could have had him come some other time during the year, not commencement, because it was supposed to be about seniors today, and a lot of my friends and myself feel like it wasn’t,” she said.

During his speech, Obama addressed the controversy surrounding the speaking engagement, while also discussing the current state of the world, the challenge of living together in peace as “one human family,” Notre Dame tradition and Catholic tradition.

“I enjoyed it,” Eileen Murphy said.

Murphy, a Lee, N.H., native, graduated with a degree in architecture.

“It was obviously a response to the controversy that’s been going on, and I thought it was appropriate that he addressed the controversy. And he twisted it in a nice way so that was university applicable to all of us, unifying our communities around us whenever there’s a problem that comes up,” she said. “I thought it was well-fitted to the situation and addressed the situation appropriately.”

One attendee, a Fogelsville, Pa., resident, said he enjoyed the speeches given by both Obama and Notre Dame President, the Rev. John Jenkins.

“Father Jenkins’ speech was great and certainly Barack Obama’s speech was great. They did a nice job of addressing the issue at hand, they didn’t dodge the fact that it was a controversial visit, and I thought they did a real classy job of meeting in the middle,” Tom Thielen said.

Thielen’s son, Joel, graduated with a degree from the Mendoza College of Business at Notre Dame.

“Obama’s obviously a very engaging speaker, disarming the crowd and getting them loose before he launched into the serious part of his speech, and I thought that was as animated and passionate as I’ve seen Father Jenkins speak before,” he said.

Marlene Daut, who graduated with a doctorate in English, was even more glowing in her reaction.

“It was by far the best that I’ve ever heard, but it’s probably the most distinguished speaker I’ve ever heard also,” she said.

She said most of the graduate students, who had already received their degrees Saturday, probably would not have attended the main ceremony had Obama not been the speaker.

“I liked how he addressed the controversy but he also spoke from a nuanced perspective, that it’s not just a black-and-white issue, that there are many places in between, and that if people want to reduce the numbers of abortions then they have to actually work to make that happen, they can’t just be opposed to it but not support any kind of reform,” Daut said.

President Obama was the sixth United States president to speak at a Notre Dame commencement ceremony, and the ninth to be awarded an honorary degree.

Text Only

Breaking News

Critics troubled by changes in child services
The number of reports of child abuse and neglect that have been determined not to merit further investigation has more than doubled statewide since Indiana's Department of Child Services moved to a centralized call center.

February 11, 2012
Coroner: South Bend hiker found in Va. was suffocated
An autopsy has concluded that an Indiana man whose body was found off the Appalachian Trail in Virginia was suffocated.

February 11, 2012
Howe. man accused of faking death going to prison
A northern Indiana man authorities say faked his own death is heading to prison after pleading guilty to passport fraud and identity theft.

February 11, 2012
'Pancake Club' makes a difference
They make pancakes — lots of pancakes. The Exchange Club of Elkhart County is even known as “The Pancake Club.”

February 11, 2012 1 Photo
Local boy receives hearing aid help
Seven-year-old Alex Rial is quick with a hug. He has a sweet smile and an engaging personality. He loves going to church and isn’t afraid to talk about his faith. In short, Alex is a special kid.

February 11, 2012 1 Photo
Election 2012: Contests set for primary
There will be races for one County Commissioner seat and seven will seek three at-large posts on the County Council in the Republican primary election this year.

February 11, 2012 1 Photo
Daniels would consider post under GOP president
Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels, who decided last year against a presidential run, says he would consider serving in the Cabinet of a new Republican president but believes it’s “very improbable” the eventual nominee would tap him as a running mate.

February 10, 2012 1 Photo
Finding the perfect filler for your garden
Rose mallow is a great garden filler. It’s origins are the genus malvaceae (mallow family) and if you are like I am, the mallow family gets rather confusing.

February 10, 2012 1 Photo
Driver killed in Nappanee crash
An Albion driver was killed in a car-truck head-on crash in Nappanee at 8:55 a.m. Friday.

February 10, 2012
SLIDESHOW: Daddy-Daughter Dance Dads took their daughters out for a night of dancing during the annual Daddy-Daughter Dance in the Community Building of the Elkhart County Fairgrounds Thursday night. The event was sold out, according to organizers.
February 10, 2012 1 Photo
More Breaking News Headlines

The Goshen Housing Authority has a $571,050 shortfall. Should the Goshen City Council use money from its $4.7-million “rainy day” fund to pay the debt and maintain the current level of service provided by the voucher program?

Breaking News

Search Results

Obama has critics, supporters at ND

The Goshen Housing Authority has a $571,050 shortfall. Should the Goshen City Council use money from its $4.7-million “rainy day” fund to pay the debt and maintain the current level of service provided by the voucher program?

Site Map