INDIANAPOLIS — Gov.-elect Mike Pence has ruled out building a state-run health insurance exchange but appears to be leaving open the option of running a joint venture with the federal government as a critical decision deadline draws near.
State leaders have until Friday to declare whether they will manage their own programs for providing insurance plans under the federal health care law. And even though he won’t be inaugurated for another six weeks, Pence will provide Indiana’s answer to the Department of Health and Human Services under an arrangement outgoing Gov. Mitch Daniels worked out with this year’s gubernatorial candidates.
Pence, a longtime opponent of President Barack Obama’s law, has said a state-run exchange would be too expensive and also has cast doubt on expanding the number eligible for Medicaid. But opposing a state exchange would not necessarily rule out a “hybrid” system of state control over federal resources, based on deadlines set by the Obama administration.
“It’s just one step at a time,” Pence spokeswoman Christy Denault said Wednesday. “Obviously Mike has been clear on his positions. We’ll simply be expressing that again to the governor before Friday’s deadline.”
On the face of it, uninsured Indiana residents are unlikely to notice much difference between a federal health insurance exchange, hybrid plan or state-run system in the coming years.
Any option would involve residents logging onto a website and selecting pre-approved health plans with basic amounts of coverage and, according to estimates provided by the state to Indiana’s gubernatorial candidates this summer, cost roughly $400 a month.
Open enrollment for exchange plans is scheduled to start Oct. 1, 2013, and coverage will be effective Jan. 1, 2014.
“To the consumer there should not be a major difference between the models,” said Caroline Pearson, director in the health reform practice at Avelere Health Care, which advises health providers on the law. “... You’re going to have a website where you buy insurance, and it shouldn’t matter a lot to the consumer whether that website is designed and run by the federal government or designed and run by the state.”
Behind the scenes, however is a much more complicated situation involving political positioning and determining whether officials in Indiana or Washington, D.C., will bear the responsibility of building an extensive new health care infrastructure for the state.
Pence’s opposition to a state-run exchange may be based on principle, but it’s also smart politics, said Bob Laszewski, president of Health Policy and Strategy Associates, a Washington-based firm advising health insurers on the new law.
If the Obama administration builds and runs an exchange it would not only bear the costs but also the responsibility for any failures, he said. And if the exchange is a shining success, Pence can swoop in and take it over after a year, he said.
“There’s really no downside to Pence in letting the feds come in and build an exchange because he can come in and take it over within a year,” he said.
It could also save Indiana money. The Pence campaign estimated building an exchange would cost the state $50 million a year. Pearson pointed out, however, that the Obama administration is offering grants to states to offset most, if not all, of that cost.
Mike Ripley, Indiana Chamber of Commerce vice president for health care policy and workforce safety, said there could be some leeway for Pence if he places residents in the federal exchange because of a possible loophole that would allow employers to avoid penalties for not covering workers. That theory has not been tested in court, he notes, but is popular among conservatives and being pushed by the Washington-based Cato Institute.
The chamber is pushing for the state to run its own exchange, despite the new costs, because of the autonomy that would come with such a move. Ripley notes that adding to the uncertainty from the incoming Pence administration and the federal government, is the potential the Indiana General Assembly will want a say when it reconvenes in January.
“Our opinion about all of these things is very fluid,” he said. “There’s so much uncertainty.”
Breaking News
Pence not ruling out health insurance partnership with feds
- Breaking News
-
-
Council declines to fund sidewalks near schools
The Goshen City Council voted 4-3 along party lines Tuesday night to defeat a proposal to spend $62,500 on constructing sidewalks near schools in the city.
-
'Experience Michiana' segments to be taped in Goshen
The crew with WNIT program “Experience Michiana” is set to tape segments in Goshen this week. The segments will be broadcast June 27 and 28.
-
State officials warn people to be alert at fairs, festivals
The Indiana Department of Homeland Security and state police are reminding state residents to be alert for safety concerns when attending county fairs and other local festivals.
-
Goshen officials donate former Hawks Building to LaCasa
An agreement between Goshen city government and LaCasa Inc. allowing for the donation of the former Hawks Building to the local non-profit was approved Monday.
-
How to monitor a Facebook Page while out of the office
With the popularity of social media soaring by the day, it is important for online marketers to keep their Facebook page updated regularly, and monitor it daily to answer comments and questions that fans post.
-
GROUNDS FOR INSANITY: In need of a support group — or several
It’s an idea whose time has come. Actually, the country’s been ripe for it since the oil crisis of the Carter administration, but I was young then and hadn’t twigged to it yet.
-
Rocket Science gains some national exposure
NAPPANEE — Things were buzzing at Rocket Science Ice Cream Shop on a recent Friday when camera crews from The Food Network and The Cooking Channel arrived at the shop inside Coppes Commons.
-
Fabric repurposed for medical uses at local nursing home
NAPPANEE - One person’s trash is another’s treasure, the old saying goes. For a group of women at a nursing home in Nappanee, that saying has never been more true.
-
Welcome back, Inn: Oakwood Reopens
SYRACUSE — After five years of uncertainty, the Oakwood Resort on Lake Wawasee checked in its first guests under new ownership last week.
-
Christian music festival returns to Nappanee
NAPPANEE — For the second year in a row, Amish Acres is the host site for WFRN Radio’s Friend Fest, scheduled for Friday and Saturday.
- More Breaking News Headlines
-
Council declines to fund sidewalks near schools




