The weak case for a hate crimes law

Opinion

June 26, 2009

Anonymous The Goshen News Fri Jun 26, 2009, 10:35 AM EDT

Attorney General Eric Holder told Congress Thursday that a new, federal hate crimes law is needed. We are not as convinced as Mr. Holder.

Hate crime legislation is a continuing debate in Congress and in many statehouses across the country. The idea to prosecute people for their motives when they commit crimes came about after the horrible murder of Matthew Shepard in Wyoming in 1998. Shepard was a gay man and he was tortured and murdered by men who hated him because of his sexual orientation. Yet, the perpetrators were successfully prosecuted for murder without a hate crimes statute. It’s hard to figure out how a hate crime law would have aided those prosecutions.

The idea of punishing people because of their hatred for others is attractive. Why shouldn’t neo-Nazis, Ku Klux Klan members and others who hate based on race or religion be punished for their motives? We have to remember that if they commit a crime, their deed, no matter what their motive, will be punished under current laws. For instance, in Indiana a murderer can either face a death sentence or a maximum sentence of 65 years in prison. Passing a federal hate crime law to punish the same murderer seems redundant and unnecessary.

But, we realize there is a large number of people who believe such legislation would be good for society as a whole. Having a hate crimes law on the books would provide a societal marker that states we as a people won’t tolerate such behavior and will punish anyone who victimizes someone based on their race, gender, sexual orientation or religion. In others words, a hate crimes law would be good public relations for Americans as a whole. Other than that purpose, a hate crimes bill would not add much to the judicial penalties already facing criminals.

We expect Congress will eventually pass some sort of hate crimes legislation due to public pressure. We also believe that law will be written into the Congressional Record and then be rarely utilized by federal prosecutors, who will realize they would be wasting their time trying someone who will also be tried on standard criminal statutes in state courts.

Text Only

Opinion

Globe’s quality is coming in loud and clear
The Globe is aptly named. Thanks to the Internet — and via globeradio.org — listeners worldwide have the opportunity to check out Goshen College’s radio station. Minus the web, local listeners can dial in to 91.1 FM and hear WGCS in about a 40-mile radius around campus.

February 11, 2012 1 Photo
Obama's action on education rule will help Indiana
It’s about time Indiana got out from under the onerous provisions of the No Child Left Behind law that was promoted by President George W. Bush and passed by Congress in 2001.

February 10, 2012
We don't want to be on this top 10 list
When it comes to being included in a top 10 list, nobody wants to be ranked as a leader in methamphetamine manufacturing. But Elkhart and Kosciusko counties have again cracked the top 10 for the number of meth labs found, this time for 2011. Elkhart County was ranked second and Kosciusko third. Vanderburgh County, way down on the Ohio River, has been awarded the infamous top spot.

February 8, 2012
Indiana's time to shine is now
During Gov. Mitch Daniels’ visit to Goshen recently, he was asked a very important, very direct question: “Who are you rooting for in Super Bowl?”

February 5, 2012
Community is proud of Skyler Carpenter
Skyler Carpenter had a choice to make.

February 4, 2012
Stahly has served his community well
There are moments that cause us to say “oh, no,” and “outstanding” nearly in the same breath. That’s how we felt recently when Bruce Stahly announced that he plans to retire as superintendent of Goshen Community Schools in June. We said “oh, no,” because we know how important Stahly has been to the school corporation for the past 13 years. And we said “outstanding,” because we know how much he deserves this after a job well done.
Stahly came to Goshen in 1999 as deputy superintendent. He had worked previously as the assistant superintendent of finance for the South Bend Community School Corp. In July 2002 Stahly was promoted to superintendent of Goshen’s schools. That was a great decision by school trustees.

February 3, 2012
Digital technology good for education
Things have changed in education and today has been set aside to encourage educators to embrace those changes.

February 1, 2012
Tommy W. Woodworth
January 31, 2012
Behavior of teens must improve during First Fridays
Goshen’s downtown has a success story, and the tale gets told every month.

January 28, 2012
Solar panels should have limited placement in cities
Goshen resident Marvin Bartel has won approval for his solar array on a vacant lot along College Avenue, which is something we have mixed feelings about.

January 26, 2012
More Opinion Headlines

The Goshen Housing Authority has a $571,050 shortfall. Should the Goshen City Council use money from its $4.7-million “rainy day” fund to pay the debt and maintain the current level of service provided by the voucher program?

Opinion

Search Results

The weak case for a hate crimes law

The Goshen Housing Authority has a $571,050 shortfall. Should the Goshen City Council use money from its $4.7-million “rainy day” fund to pay the debt and maintain the current level of service provided by the voucher program?

Site Map