Eliminate property taxes in Indiana

August 2, 2007

Anonymous The Goshen News Thu Aug 02, 2007, 08:52 AM EDT

Editor:

On July 30 you printed a letter to the editor by a Mr. David A. Shepard who attempted to make a case for eliminating our property taxes and replacing them with graduated income taxes. Among several excellent points made by Mr. Shepard was the statement that, “If property tax exists it can raise again.” I personally believe that Mr. Shepard has hit the nail squarely on the head.

Among all the proposals that have been offered to date to provide us with “meaningful property tax relief,” nearly all of them amount to nothing more than Band-Aid therapy. One such proposal tossed around over the last few weeks, as reported in The Goshen News, proposes to cut property taxes by as much as 30 percent through a combination of tax adjustments and credits.

Great. What this means is that our property taxes will be back to where they were before we suffered this most recent, painful increase. With sales and income taxes somewhat higher, the property tax will simply have a new base from which to rise in the years ahead. This is completely unacceptable.

I believe there is another good justification for eliminating property taxes. For one thing, property taxes are based on the ultimate value of a property if it were to be sold and not on an individual’s ability to pay the tax.

A widow or a single mother with children might be sitting on a property that has become quite valuable but have limited income. The value of a farmer’s land near an expanding urban area can soar but his income from farming can be quite modest. What is he supposed to do?

The fairest tax is a graduated income tax. The size of a person’s annual income can be easily and readily measured and is probably the most accurate way to assess his or her ability to pay tax.

Most ironically, on the same page with Mr. Shepard’s letter, there was also a column by Morton Marcus titled “Property Tax Needed.” There have been times in the past when I have disagreed with Mr. Marcus and that is most certainly the case again this time.

Among many of the points espoused by Mr. Marcus was the statement that “Unsubsidized property taxes help constrain urban sprawl.” I wonder if Mr. Marcus has any concrete, verifiable evidence to support this theory. I personally suspect that the exact opposite may be the case. Urban sprawl causes land values near large cities to soar and farmers or other landowners hurt by the tax are encouraged to sell, usually to a housing developer. Furthermore, exorbitant property taxes encourage homeowners to move farther out into the distant suburbs or “exurbs” in search of communities with lower (for a while) property taxes.

The best course of action, in my opinion, would be an amendment to the Indiana State Constitution that would remove the right of the state and local governments to collect property taxes. Lawmakers would then have no choice but to find alternate and fairer ways to raise money and, if necessary, make some cuts where appropriate. Just such an amendment has been presented to the Indiana Legislature. The time has clearly come for bold action. We need real action and not more Band-Aids.

Fred M. Cain,

4830 S. 500 West

Topeka

Text Only

Letters to the Editor

Donations can help house families
I read with concern the headline in The Goshen News on Wednesday. Our Goshen Housing Authority needs $571,050 to continue the local rent assistance voucher program and avoid slashing services. That is over half a million dollars. Coming up with that large an amount seems hopeless. The related article went on to say that 71 households with 126 children could be directly affected by this shortfall. That is $8,043 per family unit or $4,532 per child.

February 8, 2012
Don't punish renters for sins of housing authority
February 8, 2012
Bishop says HHS rules violate separation of church and state
On Friday, Jan. 20th, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced that almost all employers, including Catholic employers, will be forced to offer their employees health coverage that includes sterilization, abortion-inducing drugs and contraception. Almost all health insurers will be forced to include those “services” in the health policies they write. And almost all individuals will be forced to buy that coverage as a part of their policies.

February 4, 2012
Cut of Rieth Interpretive Center part-time coordinator will be felt
Praise, lament and wish encompass my feelings for the termination of the part-time position of program coordinator for the Rieth Interpretive Center in the Goshen Parks Department. Praise is for Melissa Kinsey’s effective, “full-time” effort in being the right person in the right place to work at the purpose for the RIC.

February 3, 2012
Camp director grateful for support
February 3, 2012
Repentence needed for recovery
Repentance. As Christians we are to turn away from our sins. We want to live holy lives as God wants us to live.

February 2, 2012
Legion raises funds for cancer treatment
Just to let you know that the Sons of the American Legion and Legion members of the American Legion Post 210 in Middlebury raised $1,346.00 for Sam Grewe’s family to help with the costs of his cancer treatment.

February 2, 2012
Action on global warming needed to mitigate damage
February 1, 2012
Why not add to 'sister city' family
Who knew Goshen has an international sister city?

January 28, 2012
We need more transparency in our Elkhart County government
Has anyone attended a meeting of the Elkhart County Commissioners lately? I have, and there’s good news and bad news.

January 28, 2012
More Letters to the Editor Headlines

Gov. Mitch Daniels signed the right-to-work bill into law Feb. 1, allowing Indiana workers to opt out of paying mandatory union dues at union shops. What effect do you feel the new law will have on Indiana in the future?

Letters to the Editor

Search Results

Eliminate property taxes in Indiana

Gov. Mitch Daniels signed the right-to-work bill into law Feb. 1, allowing Indiana workers to opt out of paying mandatory union dues at union shops. What effect do you feel the new law will have on Indiana in the future?

Site Map