INDIANAPOLIS — A political fight at the Indiana Statehouse over a contentious labor bill has put the state in the national spotlight, capturing the attention of NFL players, the New York Times, and national political commentators.
Even Sports Illustrated has taken notice. The magazine posted a wire story on its website Friday that said the professional football players’ union had accused Indiana Republicans who control the Statehouse are trying to “ram through” the so-called “right to work” legislation before next month’s Super Bowl is played in Indianapolis.
The statement from the National Football League Players Association was issued shortly before a Senate labor committee advanced the bill for the full Senate to vote on next week. After the committee vote, House Minority Leader Patrick Bauer stalled action on the House version of the bill for the third day in a row, by keeping most members of his caucus away from a quorum vote.
He took the action the day after he was interviewed on MSNBC by liberal political commentator Ed Schultz.
Friday’s Senate committee hearing was covered by a New York Times reporter and photographer. Along with a crowd of lobbyists, legislators, union members, business owners, other media, they sat through hours of often conflicting testimony.
The legislation would make it a misdemeanor crime for an employer to enter into a labor contract that requires all workers in a collective bargaining unit to pay union dues or fees.
Indiana Chamber of Commerce Kevin Brinegar said the law would lure union-averse companies into Indiana and create more jobs.
Retired Indiana University economist Morton Marcus said the law would interfere with private-sector contract rights and “reinforce Indiana’s image as a mean-spirited and backward state.”
Much of the testimony followed suit. Bill backers brought in the president of the Oklahoma Chamber of Commerce to tout his state’s economic growth since 2001, when Oklahomans passed a referendum approving a “right to work” law. That testimony was countered by University of Oregon economist Gordon Lafer who said one-third fewer companies have moved into Oklahoma since the law was passed.
The legislation is getting national attention because no state has passed a “right to work” law since Oklahoma did. Indiana would become the 23rd state with such a law, and the first in nation’s traditional manufacturing belt.
The politically divisive nature of the bill was illustrated during the hearing by an exchange between Republican Sen. Carlin Yoder of Middlebury, the Senate’s bill author, and Democrat Sen. Tim Skinner of Terre Haute, a leading opponent of the legislation.
Yoder said the legislation would free workers from mandatory union dues and would compel unions to have to prove their value to members.
“This is not an anti-labor bill,” Yoder said.
Skinner said he was suspect of that claim, citing recent state actions that diminished the role of public sector unions.
“This is a union-busting state,” he said. “First it was public employees. Then...it was the teachers unions. And now it’s the trade unions.”
The only Republican committee member to vote against the bill was Sen. Brent Waltz of Greenwood. He said he wanted to amend the bill to exempt the building and construction trade unions. That exemption was included in last year’s version of the bill. After the hearing, Yoder said he would oppose Waltz’s amendment and any other exemptions to the legislation.
Maureen Hayden is the Statehouse bureau chief for the CNHI newspapers in Indiana. She can be reached at maureen.hayden@indianamediagroup.com
Local News
Related Photos
-
Democrat State Sen. Tim Skinner of Terre Haute, left, a member of the Senate labor committee, questions Republican State Sen. Carlin Yoder of Middlebury about right-to-work legislation Friday, Jan. 6,2012. Yoder is one of the authors of the bill that has prompted protests at the Statehouse. House Democrats have stalled the start the House session to delay action on the bill. MAUREEN HAYDEN
Indiana's 'right to work' battle attracts national attention
Sen. Carlin Yoder defends his stance on chamber floor
- Local News
-
-
New ambulance rates moving forward
NAPPANEE — Nappanee City Council members on Tuesday voted to approve an ordinance amending ambulance rates and charges on second reading. There is still one more reading before the new rates become official.
-
Joan Collaso concert Friday at Lerner
Emmy award winner Joan Collaso will return to Elkhart for a performance at the Lerner Theatre Friday.
-
Noise to get a second look
MIDDLEBURY — Although a noise complaint leveled against an established grocery store in Middlebury has been met with cooperation from the store owner in resolving the problem for now, the complaint is leading to a full-fledged review of the town’s existing noise ordinance.
-
Warm welcome for new but familiar leader
There is a new face at the head of Indiana University Health Goshen, and we were happy to report last week, that it is a familiar one. Randy Christophel was picked by the board of directors to succeed the retiring Jim Dague as president and chief executive officer of the organization. He is already on the job.
-
Murderer of Goshen man sentenced to 65 years
The man accused of killing a Goshen business owner last fall was sentenced to 65 years in prison during an Elkhart Circuit Court Hearing this morning at the Elkhart County Jail.
-
Plan targets college completion
Indiana higher-education policy makers are getting ready to adopt an aggressive college-completion plan that will push the state’s colleges and universities to reel in their rising costs and dramatically improve their graduation rates.
-
UPDATE: Funding plan passes
After an emotionally charged debate that lasted nearly two hours Tuesday night, the Goshen City Council voted to provide funding to bailout the Goshen Housing Authority by a vote of 6-1.
-
Watch portion sizes, plate sizes for healthy eating
February is a great month to remind you to take a look at your eating. Is it as healthy as it should be?
-
Effort to expand school voucher program fails
School choice advocates who ended the last legislative session with a bill that created the largest voucher program in the nation have been stymied this session in their efforts to expand the program's scope.
-
Police impersonator attempts to stop vehicle
According to a report by the Elkhart County Sheriff’s Department, a suspected police impersonator attempted to stop a vehicle headed east on the U.S. 20 bypass east of the Ind. 19 exit at 5:10 p.m. Friday.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Romney, Santorum Assail Each Other in GOP Debate
New Radar Confirms Tornadoes Faster
Police: Wash. School Shooting Accidental
Fitness Program Improves Lives of Mentally Ill
NJ Officials Blast NYPD Over Spying Report
2nd Degree Murder Verdict in Lacrosse Slaying
GOP Rivals Pass Contraception Debate, Hit Obama
Romney, Santorum Swap Charges in 20th Debate
Raw Video: Guilty Verdict in UVa Lacrosse Death
$5 Gas Coming to Pumps Near You?
Raw Video: French Police Release Strauss-Kahn
Ga. Spa Shooting Leaves 5 Dead, Victims Related
2 More Western Journalists Die in Syria
7 Killed As Afghan Quran Protests Turn Violent
Santorum Goes After Obama on Energy
Judge Says Lindsay Lohan in the "Home Stretch"
Father Accused of Using Leash on 11 Year Old
Obama Helps Break Ground on Black History Museum
Raw Video: Dozens Dead in Argentina Train Crash
Wounded Vets Regain Some Camaraderie in Kitchen
